Jewelry Appraisal and Gemology Located in
Fort Collins, CO

Jewelry Appraisal and Gemology Located in Fort Collins, COJewelry Appraisal and Gemology Located in Fort Collins, COJewelry Appraisal and Gemology Located in Fort Collins, CO

(970)215-5971

(970)215-5971

Jewelry Appraisal and Gemology Located in
Fort Collins, CO

Jewelry Appraisal and Gemology Located in Fort Collins, COJewelry Appraisal and Gemology Located in Fort Collins, COJewelry Appraisal and Gemology Located in Fort Collins, CO

Welcome

Welcome to Wray Jewelry Appraisals

Welcome to Wray Jewelry AppraisalsWelcome to Wray Jewelry AppraisalsWelcome to Wray Jewelry Appraisals

About Jewelry Appraisals

engagement ring for insurance appraisal or court case at Wray Jewelry Appraisal in Colorado.

Jewelry Appraisals

A jewelry appraisal  is an essential document for anyone who owns valuable jewelry. It is NOT an offer to buy jewelry or a verbal guess of the value. An appraisal provides a detailed description, an assessment of the quality and condition, and the  value of the jewelry.  This document is necessary for obtaining insurance, estate planning, divorce settlement, donating or selling jewelry. 


Wray Jewelry Appraisals can perform all types of appraisals based on your particular need, usually with a quick turn around time and while you watch.

Your jewelry never has to be out of your sight. 


Digital and hard copies provided for your convenience.

Text, call, or email now to discuss your appraisal.

Contact
 resale appraisal at Wray Jewelry Appraisals in Fort Collins, CO

Independent Appraisers

Independent appraisers ensure an unbiased evaluation of your jewelry by having no financial interest in the outcome of the appraisal. An ethical appraiser will not make an offer to buy your jewelry or base their fee on the value of the jewelry.


As an independent appraisal office, Wray Jewelry Appraisals can schedule with you directly and complete your appraisal while you wait. There is no need to wait for an extended period of time for an appointment or to have a completed appraisal.


Contact us today for the next available appointment time.

Contact
inherited jewelry  for estate valuation or legal dispute at Wray Jewelry Appraisals in  Colorado

Appraisal Updates

Did you know gold and diamond prices fluctuate over time like the stock market?

Because of that, the value of your jewelry can change and an outdated appraisal may not accurately reflect the current market value of your jewelry, which could lead to inadequate insurance coverage in the event of a loss.


 Up-to-date appraisal documents are also important for estate planning to ensure a fair and equitable distribution of family heirlooms. 


At Wray Jewelry Appraisals, digital and hard copies are provided to make it easy to update your insurance policy.


Contact us today to schedule your appointment.

Contact

About Gemstone Consultation

GIA gemologist and expert witness examining diamond in Colorado

A gemstone consultant provides guidance on the selection, evaluation and acquisition of gemstones based on gemological knowledge and training. As an expert gemologist, a consultant can offer advice on the quality and authenticity of gemstones. 


Wray Jewelry Appraisals uses standard and advanced gemological  techniques and instruments such as a UV-VIS-NIR spectroscope to make identifications and recommendations before, during, and after you purchase a diamond, pearls, or a colored gemstone.

Contact

About Expert Witness Services

Melinda Wray, FGA, GG, RGA, CM (NAJA), of Wray Jewelry Appraisals stands out as the premier choice in Northern Colorado for an expert witness and consultant in all areas of legal consideration and proceedings. Her extensive and on-going gemological and appraisal education, along with a commitment to excellence, ensures she will provide invaluable support for your case or investigation.


Contact Wray Jewelry Appraisals today to learn more.

Expert witness from Wray Jewelry Appraisals in Fort Collins investigating for trial.

About The Gemologist Appraiser

Melinda Wray, FGA, GG, RGA, Certified Member NAJA

Melinda is an experienced gemologist appraiser with the unusual distinction of being both a Fellow of the Gemmological Association of Great Britain (FGA) and a GIA Graduate Gemologist (GG). It is relatively rare to find a gemologist who holds both of these distinguished diplomas in addition to having specific training as a jewelry appraiser. She maintains the most up-to-date education of any appraiser or gemologist in the Northern Colorado Front Range area and continues to pursue the highest level of appraisal and gemological knowledge through continuing education and training.


EDUCATION:

  • Fellow, Gemmological Association of Great Britain, 2022
  • Graduate Gemologist with Pearl Diploma, Gemological Institute of America, 2019
  • Registered Gemologist Appraiser, United States Gemological Institute, 2019
  • Pearl Specialist, Cultured Pearl Association of America, 2021
  • Expert Witness and Litigation Training, United States Gemological Institute, January 2026
  • Certificate in Opal Studies, Gemmological Association of Australia, 2026
  • Jewelry Forensics, GIA, 2019
  • History of Jewelry Design, Christie's
  • Current Certified Member of the National Association of Jewelry Appraisers (NAJA)
  • Gem-a Conference, London, England, 2018, 2022, 2023, 2025
  • NAJA Conference,  January 2024, August 2025, January 2026




Gemologist appraiser examining a gemstone in Fort Collins, Colorado.

What Others Have to Say:

"My store carried a higher end inventory and it was always so beneficial to get Melinda"s second opinion on high end jewelry purchases that I was making. Where I have 50 years of experience, it was nice to also have her help in making educated decisions during my diamond buying appointments. She is impeccably honest, reliable, knowledgeable, and dependable. I will continue to use Melinda's services whenever I need an honest, concise opinion."

-Susan Harrison, President/Owner

  Jewelry Emporium

  Fort Collins, CO


"Melinda is extremely knowledgeable and dedicated. If there's something she doesn't know, she spends careful time collecting necessary research to give an accurate assessment. On top of all this, she's incredibly friendly and easy to work with -- would highly recommend her to anybody!"

-Andrew, appraisal client

  Greeley. CO


"Melinda is our trusted expert for help with all things sparkly! Whether you need an appraisal for insurance purposes or help in making a sound purchase decision, she will give you an accurate, swift assessment perfect for your needs."

-Dru and Kim, appraisal and gemstone clients

  Idaho Springs, CO


”Melinda was thorough in sorting my father’s estate. Her knowledge allows me to pass on details to family members as to the value of certain pieces.”

-anonymous 

  Fort Collins, CO


”Melinda was kind, very approachable, and professional. I highly recommend her!”

-Marcie, appraisal customer

  Fort Collins, CO


"Great experience and explanation of jewelry appraisal."

-Corey,  appraisal customer

  Wellington, CO


"Highly knowledgable and very professional. Would highly recommend Melinda Wray at Wray Jewelry Appraisals!"

-Margo, appraisal customer

  Loveland, CO



Frequently Asked Questions

Please reach us at wrayappraisals@gmail.com if you cannot find an answer to your question.

Absolutely! Your jewelry never has to leave your sight.

Allow approximately one hour per piece of jewelry.  You might want to bring a book to read or something else to do. Or consider dropping off your pieces, running an errand and coming back in about an hour.


That depends on what you intend to do with the jewelry.  The price someone will pay you to buy it is different than the amount an insurance company will pay you to replace it if you experience a loss.


No.  There are many factors which can affect the value and those can only be determined with an in-person inspection. A trained and ethical appraiser will not do over the phone valuations. 


No. If the appraiser guesses too low or too high, there is no benefit for you and it puts the appraiser's reputation at risk.


No. It is unethical for a jewelry appraiser to make an offer to buy your jewelry. 


A store owner or employee may not have the specific appraisal training or gemology credentials to write an appraisal that would meet the standards required by an insurance company for an appraisal document. Plus, the store owner or employee may have a conflict of interest and assign a biased value.


Yes. Most insurance companies recommend jewelry appraisals be updated every three to five years or if there is a change to your policy. The prices of precious metals and gemstones can fluctuate up or down which will affect the value of your jewelry. Plus, now you can receive digital copies of your appraisal to make it easy to update your insurance. 


1. People who switch diamonds either go to jail or retire early.

2. I am not willing to risk my reputation or career for your diamond.

3. If this is a concern for you, you are welcome to stay and watch while I work, even if it is a multi-item appraisal that takes all day.


That depends on why you need a value:

  • Insurance appraisals provide an accurate description and a replacement value so your insurance company can provide an appropriate amount of coverage to replace your item in the event of a loss.
  • Resale appraisals help you to determine an asking price when  you want to sell your jewelry.
  • Fair market value appraisals are used for estate planning, charitable donations, divorce settlement, and other similar situations. It determines the price a willing buyer would pay a willing seller in a transaction where neither is forced or coerced to buy or sell.


Besides the jewelry, bring all related documents - receipts, past appraisals, diamond reports, etc. Also, anything that indicates  the age of the piece - letters, notes, receipts, etc. You might also want to bring a book to read or something to do while you wait.


You will receive paper and digital copies of your appraisal that meet the standards of the National Association of Jewelry Appraisers. This will include, among other things, a detailed description of your jewelry with specific gemstone grading information and multiple photos of your item In addition to the value specific to the purpose of the appraisal.


I do not appraise watches at this time. 


Fees

Appraisals

Price per piece unless otherwise noted. Free in-person consultation. Paper and digital copies available. *Additional fees may be applied for missed scheduled appointments.*

One Item of Jewelry

$130.00

Allow one hour for the appointment.

Items 2-5 appraised at the same time as the first one

$95.00 per piece up to five pieces

Allow one hour per piece.

Items 6-15 appraised at the same time

$85.00 per piece after the first five

More than 15 items appraised at the same time

$85.00 per item

Half of estimated cost due before work begins. Balance due upon completion.

Estate sorting

$150/hr

Determining what is real, what is costume, and what is worth a formal appraisal. 

Updates on appraisals by Wray Jewelry Appraisals within 5 years

$75.00 per piece

Gemstone Consultation

Gem Identification only

$50.00 for one stone

$35.00 per stone for each additional stone identified at the same time. This includes an identification report but no valuation. Estimates available for large collections. 

Gemstone Appraisal - includes ID and value

$130.00 for one stone

$95 each for stones 2-5 appraised at the same time. $85  each for stones 6-15 appraised at the same time. $75 each for more than 15 stones appraised at the same time.

Pre-Purchase Consultation

$130.00

Examination of a gem under consideration for purchase to verify identity and value. 

Purchase Verification

$130.00

Examination to verify the identity, characteristics, and value of a recently purchased gemstone.

Diamond Grading and Plotting

$130.00

Expert Witness Services and Consultation

Fees available upon request

Contact Us

How can we help?

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Appointments typically available in two to three business days.

BY APPOINTMENT ONLY

Call or text (970)215-5971 Please bring all documents related to your jewelry such as receipts, diamond reports, past appraisals, etc., to your appointment. *To keep the schedule running smoothly, please arrive on time or call to reschedule.

Hours

Mon

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Tue

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Wed

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Thu

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Fri

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Sat

Closed

Sun

Closed

Saturday appointments may be available upon request.

*Additional fees may be applied for missed scheduled appointments.


Copyright © 2026 Wray Jewelry Appraisals - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept